Top 5 Players Who Played for Both Liverpool and Everton

Who are the best players who have dared to wear both the red and blue jerseys in Merseyside?

When it comes to the intense football rivalry between Liverpool and Everton, few players have dared to cross the Merseyside divide and wear the colors of both clubs.

Here’s a look at five notable players who left their mark on both sides of this passionate derby.

5. Gary Ablett

Starting his career in the red of Liverpool, Gary Ablett showcased his versatility as a defender, making 147 appearances and scoring one goal for the Reds. His association with Liverpool saw him win two league titles. However, in 1992, Ablett made the controversial switch to Everton. He went on to play 156 games and netted six goals for the Toffees. Ablett made history as the first player to win the FA Cup with both clubs when Everton triumphed in 1995, etching his name in Merseyside folklore.

4. David Johnson

David Johnson made his presence felt on both sides of the Merseyside rivalry for over 15 years. Born in Liverpool, he first plied his trade at Everton, netting 20 goals in 92 appearances. However, it was his time at Liverpool that truly defined his career. Johnson played 213 games for the Reds, scoring a remarkable 78 goals. A true goal poacher, he contributed to Liverpool’s glory years with four league titles, two European Cups, and a League Cup. In 1982, he surprised many by moving to Everton, coming full circle in his Merseyside journey.

3. Steve McMahon

Steve McMahon’s story is one of passion and determination that bridges the divide between the two rival clubs. Starting as a ball-boy at Everton, McMahon’s dream came true when he began his professional career with the Toffees, earning 119 appearances and 14 goals. Yet, it was his move across Stanley Park to Liverpool that propelled him to greater fame. Under Kenny Dalglish, McMahon claimed three league titles and two FA Cups among other accolades, cementing his legacy as a key figure in Liverpool’s midfield.

2. Peter Beardsley

Peter Beardsley’s dribbling skills and flair made him a standout player in both the Liverpool and Everton lineups. Arriving at Liverpool in 1987, Beardsley contributed to the club’s successes, including two league titles and an FA Cup. His dazzling performances earned him a reputation as a fan-favorite. In 1991, Beardsley made the surprising switch to Everton, where he quickly endeared himself to the Toffees’ faithful. He became only the second player to score in a Merseyside derby for both clubs, highlighting his unique place in the history of the rivalry.

1. Kevin Sheedy

Kevin Sheedy’s journey is one of twists and turns that led to him becoming a legend at Everton. Though he initially joined Liverpool, he only made a handful of appearances and scored two goals. However, it was at Everton that he truly shone. Sheedy’s left foot was a weapon that helped him score 97 goals in 356 games, establishing himself as a key figure in the Blues’ midfield. With four major honors to his name, including two league titles and an FA Cup, Sheedy left an indelible mark on Everton’s history.