In football, individual brilliance is great—but it’s chemistry that wins trophies.
Some of the most iconic teams in history were built around legendary duos or trios—think Xavi and Iniesta, or Messi, Neymar, and Suárez. But what happens when two brilliant players just can’t gel on the pitch?
Here are five football pairs that, despite their star power, have struggled to shine together.
1. Rasmus Højlund & Alejandro Garnacho – Manchester United
This pairing sounds like a dream on paper. Højlund is a powerful striker with shades of Erling Haaland, while Garnacho is a dynamic winger who idolizes Cristiano Ronaldo and plays alongside Lionel Messi for Argentina.
Both are young and immensely talented. So what’s the problem?
They both thrive on the left flank. Højlund’s strength lies in his hold-up play and central presence, while Garnacho prefers to cut in from the left wing. Their tendency to occupy the same zones leads to poor balance and frequent clashes in attacking movements. Add to that the chaos in United’s attack, and it becomes clear why this duo hasn’t exploded the way fans hoped.
Will they figure it out with time? Possibly. But only if they’re given the time to develop together.
2. Harry Maguire & Victor Lindelöf – Manchester United
When these two start together, Manchester United fans brace themselves. Both defenders are good passers but lack pace and positional awareness. Together, they’re a recipe for defensive instability.
In 190 appearances, Lindelöf’s partnership with Maguire has produced:
- 48 clean sheets
- 202 goals conceded
“Like driving with both brakes on,” as one fan memorably put it. They don’t complement each other—Maguire’s lapses and Lindelöf’s hesitancy mean there’s no safety net when things go wrong.
3. Vinícius Júnior & Kylian Mbappé – Real Madrid
When Mbappé finally made the long-anticipated move to Real Madrid, fans were ready to witness magic. On paper, a frontline with Vinícius and Mbappé was unstoppable.
In reality? It’s a tactical headache.
Both stars are most comfortable on the left, cutting inside and carrying the ball. Ancelotti has tried pushing Mbappé into the central striker role, but old habits die hard. Mbappé often drifts left, which crowds Vinícius out of his optimal zone.
Yes, the team still wins thanks to individual brilliance, but the overlap in styles and areas occupied creates an ongoing dilemma that no manager can easily solve. Dropping either player? Not an option.
4. João Félix & Nicolas Jackson – Chelsea FC
João Félix once looked destined for greatness. But now? He’s become a symbol of wasted potential.
Chelsea brought Félix back after his loan spell, but the arrival of Nicolas Jackson created a stylistic clash. Jackson is a poacher who thrives off the shoulder of defenders, while Félix loves to roam around the final third—often dropping into spaces Jackson wants to run into.
Result? Confusion, isolation, and a blunt attack.
New manager Enzo Maresca seems to have chosen Jackson as his main man, and Félix may soon be on his way out. A sad fall for a once-hyped Ballon d’Or contender.
5. Darwin Núñez & Diogo Jota – Liverpool FC
This one isn’t as obvious—until you look deeper.
Both Núñez and Jota are left-footed, love cutting in from the right, and crash the box with similar timing. Problem is, so does Mo Salah, arguably Liverpool’s most important player.
When all three play, the right side becomes overcrowded. Núñez and Jota also make similar runs between defenders, which leads to a jumbled attacking shape.
Despite moments of brilliance, the trio’s dynamic is inconsistent at best. With Arne Slot expected to revamp the squad this summer, both Núñez and Jota could be facing exits.
Final Thoughts
Sometimes, having two world-class players isn’t enough. Football is about systems, chemistry, and balance. As these five duos show, even the most talented stars can clash rather than complement.
Be sure not to miss out on the latest news about Chelsea
Download our brand new App and follow your favorite players, clubs, and much more
