Top 5 Backup Goalkeepers Who Deserve to Start

The goalkeeper is undeniably one of the most crucial roles on the field, and the world’s top teams rely on exceptional talent in this position.

Yet, goalkeepers rarely rotate, as the number one choice is usually favored for nearly every match to keep them at peak performance. This leaves highly skilled backups with limited playing time. Here’s a look at seven talented keepers who are too good to be on the bench.

5. Martin Dubravka (Newcastle United)

Newcastle United’s second-choice keeper, Martin Dubravka, was once the club’s Player of the Year. Having joined on loan in 2018, Dubravka quickly won fans over with his reliable performances, culminating in a stellar 2020 season. Although Nick Pope is now the starting choice, Dubravka remains a dependable option. At 35, however, Dubravka’s playing career is nearing its end, and he may seek a starting role elsewhere.

4. Wojciech Szczesny (Barcelona)

Barcelona’s backup, Wojciech Szczesny, has plenty of experience as Juventus’s former number one for seven seasons. Following Marc-André ter Stegen’s injury, Szczesny joined the Catalan giants, but manager Hansi Flick has chosen to start Inaki Pena instead. Despite this, Szczesny’s pedigree as an experienced and consistent top-level goalkeeper makes it likely he’ll earn his starting spot soon enough.

3. Andriy Lunin (Real Madrid)

Real Madrid’s Andriy Lunin has shown he can step up under pressure, especially during last season’s Champions League run when he filled in for the injured Thibaut Courtois. Lunin’s consistent performances even led some fans to suggest he should start in the Champions League final. Now back on the bench, Lunin has signed a contract extension until 2030, and at 25, he remains an exciting future prospect as Courtois, now 32, nears the twilight of his career.

2. Caoimhin Kelleher (Liverpool)

Liverpool’s backup, Caoimhin Kelleher, has made a name for himself in the few opportunities he’s had. Known for his composure, Kelleher has delivered crucial saves in multiple Carabao Cup finals and even scored a penalty in Liverpool’s 2022 shootout win over Chelsea. Though Alisson is still a world-class keeper, he’s now 32 and facing more injuries, which could eventually give Kelleher his well-deserved starting chance.

1. Stefan Ortega (Manchester City)

Stefan Ortega, Manchester City’s backup goalkeeper, is one of the best examples of an underutilized talent. The German keeper has been consistently reliable when called upon, such as during the Citizens’ FA Cup victory against Manchester United. Ortega’s transfer from Arminia Bielefeld on a free has proven a brilliant decision, with the German seamlessly stepping in for Ederson whenever needed. Although Ederson is City’s established number one, Ortega’s performance level ensures little drop-off. If Ederson were to leave, Ortega’s chance to shine as a starter might finally arrive.